Evie must come to terms with her feelings for Dylan, just as his relationship with Abigail gets more serious. Meanwhile Luke struggles in his new quest for love and Angus faces the reality of marrying someone he barely knows.
Dylan and the group attends Abigail's Literary Festival. Meanwhile Evie feels jealous that herself and Dylan had years to figure things out, while him and Abigail seem to be doing just fine. Evie moves in with Luke.
At their college reunion, Evie and Dylan encounter a ex-boyfriend of Evie's. Luke tries to avoid dealing with his feelings. Angus concocts a plan to look more accomplished to his former college friends.